by darsnowden » Mon Jun 21, 2010 12:27 am
I was at the meeting for a short time with my kids. The development's lawyer spoke with Seamus Carroll at length about the kinds of modifications the developers were looking into (and Seamus shared them with me and others):
1. Building up the land so that the development is farther above the aquifer.
2. Looking into making part of the development senior housing to reduce the number of children coming to Haldane.
The lawyer also mentioned that at present, there are mining rights that would allow the present company to drill right down to the aquifer, so really, this development would be a step up from the present situation.
Just as I was about to lament this lose-lose situation, my Philipstown friends brought me up to speed on how this is often part of the developers' playbooks: make the new (development) seem like a preferable option to the status quo of mining (apparently this scenario played out recently here in Philipstown).
Given the Huffington Post article that was circulating about this, I hope we can get to the root of this issue: protecting one of the last clean water sources in the area, one that actually helps to make the more polluted sources of water more potable, if the HP article is correct. No jam-packed development or mining operation will help that.
Also, the traffic issue is a real one.
And these problems are all besides the untenable influx of students, which, by the way, is regardless of socio-economic status, for all those who think this is a NIMBY issue about low-income kids in our school system. We must be clear with each other. It's not about income status. More than one person has expressed concerns that we are being classist here. Haldane is a very crowded place that already could use some more room--100+ kids in one year could really sink us (and *our* lower income tax payers), and this development, at first blush, is more about money (and sewage lines) than providing a truly decent living space for anyone.
Many thanks to all the members of Hudson Highlands Land Trust who showed up to put this all in a perspective they could share. And to Andrea, if she gets this, my son said of your sons, "Hey, those were boys I liked right away."
-- Dar